November 12, 2026
The market at 222 Hillspoint Road, a short walk from Old Mill Beach, has been a neighborhood store since 1919. Romanacci's has said goodbye, and no new operator has been named. The decision most likely to shape what comes back is a zoning question, and the Planning and Zoning Commission will take it up again on November 30.
The owners are asking Westport to create a new kind of zoning district, and P&Z would pick which properties go into it. That approach is a direct answer to the court ruling that struck down the last set of rules written for this store.
Romanacci's ran the market for the past three years. In September 2026 owners Graziano and Maurizio Ricci chose not to renew the lease. 06880 reported that the brothers held a farewell evening for customers, said they had enjoyed their time and had not lost money, and were turning to a new restaurant in Darien. That restaurant was slated for Heights Crossing, 346 Heights Road, across from the Noroton Heights train station, according to CT Insider.
The building belongs to the Soundview Empowerment Alliance. It's a nonprofit created by the community, and it says many hundreds of people contributed financially to save the market in 2022. In its own words on 06880, SEA has two missions. One is preserving the historic neighborhood market. The other is creating jobs and job training for young people with disabilities.
That ownership structure changes how to read the vacancy. A private landlord with an empty storefront mostly needs a tenant. A nonprofit whose purpose is keeping a neighborhood market open needs a tenant who can stay for years, and SEA's attorney has tied that durability directly to zoning.
At the October 19 public hearing, SEA attorney Eric Bernheim described what he hopes the new rules will achieve. "It makes sense for Westport, and hopefully we'll have longevity instead of change every 2 or 3 years as the operators get worn down," he said, as 06880 reported.
The owners argue that the store's economics depend on what an operator may sell and serve. Westport has already tried to answer that once. In November 2024 the commission adopted rules that allowed alcohol sales at the store. A group of neighbors sued over parking, traffic, noise and pedestrian safety. In February 2026 a Superior Court judge overturned Text Amendments 843 and 846, which had allowed alcohol sales and consumption at outdoor tables, as the Westport Journal reported.
The court's reasoning is what drives the new proposal. According to 06880's account of the ruling, the judge concluded the changes amounted to "spot zoning" and improperly expanded a non-conforming commercial use in a residential zone. The Westport Journal reports that, according to Bernheim, the Appellate Court has accepted the owners' petition to review that ruling, though a decision could take more than a year.
The new proposal, Text Amendment #875, would create a Food and Beverage Planned Development District. A companion map amendment would move 222 Hillspoint Road out of its current Residential Zone B and into that district. 06880 noted the proposal would also give P&Z stronger powers over similar establishments in otherwise residential neighborhoods. The town's planning staff recommended adding language that states the district's purpose, which is to foster "neighborhood food and beverage establishments" within "convenient walking distance" of the homes they serve.
Here is what the revised amendment text posted by the town would allow if it is adopted:
| Element | What the draft says |
|---|---|
| Permitted uses | Grocery stores, delicatessens, retail food establishments, restaurants, cafes and taverns |
| Indoor seating | Up to 20 patrons inside a Retail Food Establishment without treating it as a restaurant or requiring extra parking |
| Alcohol | Sale of alcoholic liquor for on-premises consumption within a Retail Food Establishment |
| Outdoor eating | Areas wholly within 25 feet of the principal building |
| Housing | Transit Community Middle Housing allowed by summary review, but held to the height, setback and coverage limits that applied before rezoning |
At the November 2 meeting, the seating figure went from 10 in the earlier draft to 20. Bernheim told commissioners that the rule leaves them in charge of which properties get the designation and on what terms. "You can decide whether or not you'd be comfortable with 20 patron seats for a food and retail establishment in those zones," he said, according to the Westport Journal.
Moving the site into a new district would also bring it under the town's transit community middle housing rule, which can allow multiple residential units. The added restriction holds any such project to the building-size rules of the old zoning. Bernheim noted that the existing store already exceeds zoning that was adopted long after it opened, so a housing project "probably would not work." "That's unlikely to make sense from a financial standpoint," he said.
The Old Mill Preservation Group is made up of residents who oppose alcohol sales at the store, and they are represented by counsel. They have contested the proposal at each stage. At the November 2 meeting, the Westport Journal reported, opponents said outdoor seating up to 25 feet from the building would be disruptive in summer and raised concerns about patrons parking on neighboring property.
The group's attorney questioned whether the changes are needed to preserve the market, pointing out that it operated as a grocery store for a century and was never a restaurant or bar. Opponents also worry the site could eventually become a bar, restaurant or liquor store. Bernheim pointed to the lot's parking limits in response.
Parking sits on both sides of the argument. Opponents cite it as a burden on the street, and the owners point to the same small lot. The 25-foot outdoor boundary and the 20-seat ceiling are the limits commissioners will be weighing on November 30.
Here is the order of events so far:
Nothing has been approved. 06880 framed the owners' goal as being able to sell and serve alcohol next summer if they get their way, so the 2027 beach season is the window both sides are watching. Meeting materials are posted on the town's P&Z pending applications page under 222 Hillspoint Road and the Food and Beverage Planned Development District. Anyone following the decision closely can read the draft language there before November 30 rather than relying on summaries.
This post explains a pending zoning proposal and isn't legal advice. If a rule like this could affect your own property, confirm the details with a land-use attorney or the Planning and Zoning Department.
If you live near Compo or Old Mill and want to talk about your plans, Amanda Thornton is glad to help. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, Amanda Thornton brings local market knowledge, personalized guidance, and a thoughtful approach to every real estate experience across New York and Connecticut.